Premier League's All-Time Top Goalscorers

The Premier League's all-time leading goal scorer remains the legendary Alan Shearer, who scored 260 goals during his career. Remarkably, Shearer will have held this top spot for 31 years by December, establishing a record that has yet to be surpassed.

Notable Players on the List

Alan Shearer – 260 goals
Jermain Defoe – 162 goals

History of the Record

Shearer first took the lead during the inaugural Premier League season but temporarily lost it due to a severe knee injury. Teddy Sheringham led for part of 1993 until Shearer reclaimed the top position, which he has maintained ever since.

"Incredibly, Alan Shearer will have been the Premier League’s all-time leading scorer for 31 years in December."

Future Contenders

Recent challengers have come close, yet Shearer's record seems secure especially after Harry Kane’s transfer this summer. However, with Erling Haaland scoring at an impressive rate, it may not be long before the discussion arises whether he can surpass Shearer’s record.

The frequent moves of modern footballers between clubs and leagues add uncertainty, meaning Shearer's milestone could remain unbeaten for many years.

"At the rate Erling Haaland is scoring, it probably won’t be that long until we’re pondering whether he’ll be the one to knock Shearer off his perch."

Author's summary: Alan Shearer's unmatched Premier League goal record stands strong after 31 years, but prolific scorers like Erling Haaland may challenge his legacy soon.

Opta Analyst — 2025-11-02